Overview
ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) and POAS (Profit on Ad Spend)
All marketing professionals are familiar with the ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) metric, which measures the revenue generated by a specific ad spend. This metric is widely used to assess the success of various marketing channels, campaigns, product groups, and even individual product performance. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are often set based on ROAS, advertising platforms provide features and tools to optimize for target ROAS, and skilled marketers put tremendous effort into balancing ROAS values within and between campaigns to eliminate inefficiencies.
However, despite its widespread use, we all know that revenue is a top-line metric, and what ultimately concerns businesses is the real return on ad spend – how much profit each and every advertising investment generates. Many retailers offer a range of products with vastly different levels of profitability due to various business variables and factors. Relying solely on revenue on ad spend as a KPI, target, or advertising metric is obviously flawed and deeply inefficient.
The true return on ad spend, often referred to as POAS (Profit on Ad Spend), holds more significance for businesses. Understanding the actual profit generated from each & every advertising expenditure is crucial for effective decision-making. To achieve this, it is essential to incorporate variance in profitability into reporting and campaign configuration.
However, advertising platforms and tools currently lack easy solutions to account for variance in profitability in their reporting and optimization features. As a result, many businesses resort to setting ROAS targets based on average profit margins or the break-even threshold of their lowest-profit-margin products. This approach is of course flawed and inefficient – but is there another way?
The Challenge
Hypus has been working with Client X, a well-established footwear retailer, for several years. Hypus proposed to help Client X maximize the impact of their advertising budget by introducing a POAS-focused (Profit on Ad Spend) strategy.
The plan was to delve deeper into the factors influencing profit margins, develop a framework to systematically categorize Client X’s inventory based on profit margins, and crucially to define & implement a differentiated strategy to configure the marketing campaigns to optimize for POAS.
The goal was to substantially improve the overall profitability of Client X’s marketing campaigns without increasing the spend whatsoever – giving Client X the choice of whether to bank the extra profit or allow themselves to set lower ROAS targets for their marketing campaigns & generate substantially more revenue from the existing budget.
Our Solution
Analyzing Business Factors and Inventory
Our process began by working closely with Client X to firstly identify & subsequently quantify an exhaustive list of the factors that affect profit margins on a product level. After intensive discussions covering everything including VAT regulation,shipping & handling costs, returns percentages, COGs, partnerships, marketing costs and much more we were satisfied that we had comprehensively covered all important factors and variables. One very important discussion remained. How would we deal with pricing – more specifically – discounting? Should we incorporate discounted prices into our profit margin calculations or not? After careful consideration we decided that our calculations should focus on RRP rather than sale prices as doing otherwise would essentially reverse the intended effect of the sale price. (which is to reduce the profit margin to increase demand).
Systemisation
With all involved satisfied that we had identified and quantified all factors that led to profitability variance, our attention swiftly turned to systemisation. Could we devise a methodology & system which would allow us to continuously categorize products by profit margins on a very granular level, as and when new products or information surfaced? Our analytics team got straight to work, designing & creating a user-friendly database that worked in real-time to automatically calculate the profit margins for each individual product using a series of predefined rules (incorporating all the factors that had been identified as affecting profitability variance) and actual transaction data..
Implementation
With a system in place for continuous monitoring of profitability variance we were now ready to enter the most crucial phase of the project – configuring the advertising campaigns to optimize for POAS. The challenge was of course to find the best & most efficient way to implement a differentiated strategy accounting for profitability variance, within advertising platforms that had no access to the profit margin data and no obvious way of using the features and tools available to optimize for POAS. After extensive thought we identified two possible implementation models and their pros & cons:
Option 1 – Bucketing Products into Profitability Groups
The first option involved grouping products into several buckets based on their profitability levels. Each bucket of similarly profitable products would be assigned the appropriate target ROAS to achieve a balanced POAS across the different buckets.
Pros:
- Easier to implement with less technical effort.
- Easier to add rules/overrides.
- Great visibility
Option 2 – Adding a New Purchase Conversion Action
The second option involved adding a new purchase conversion action to the website, sending Google Ads the actual profit (Revenue minus all costs of goods sold) for each sale as “conversion data”. With this data, campaigns could then be optimized using the data from the new conversion action. In effect we would be creating a Profit and POAS metric within the advertising platform allowing us to optimize for POAS in the same way we would for ROAS.
Pros:
- Allows for a highly granular differentiation strategy, with accurate profit data
- Takes into account product purchased not the product being clicked on. (A small but significant percentage of clicks result in a purchase of an altogether different product than the one clicked on).
- Compatible with other existing & future campaign structures.
- No data segmentation required
We presented Client X with the two implementation models and discussed the pros and cons of each. After careful consideration we reached the conclusion that we would indeed embark on the more ambitious of the two options, adding a new conversion action, which although a hugely technical & skillful operation would really allow for a fully differentiated profitability variance strategy that was both versatile and durable.
Work began on building an application that could systematically calculate the profit value for all website transactions, using the same predefined rules we created in the earlier stage of the project. Once calculated the application would match the transactions with those recorded in Google Ads and send an adjusted value for those conversions so that Google Ads now had a new profit conversion value in addition to the standard conversion value. If successful, we would effectively be creating a new “profit” metric within the Google Ads platform that would automatically assign a profit value to every click that led to a conversion.
After extensive work and testing, working hand in hand with Client X, we successfully developed a fully automated, highly stable system that uploaded profit values for every recorded conversion within Google Ads.
Highly confident that our solution was exhaustive, stable and most importantly game changing, we were ready to launch it on the account.
Results
After allowing some time for Google Ads to accumulate profit data for the campaigns, we began our work to guide Google to optimize for profit on ad spend rather than ROAS.
Satisfied that Google was indeed optimizing to target POAS on an original cohort of experimental campaigns, we swiftly rolled out our solution across the entire account. Our
attention quickly turned to balancing the POASs between the different campaigns so that every advertising spend was now being directed for the most profitable outcome.
The results were a fully balanced account optimizing for POAS. Without increasing advertising budget whatsoever and while maintaining the same overall ROAS, the campaigns were now utilizing the advertising budget far more efficiently. Spend was now being shifted from less profitable products to more lucrative ones, significantly enhancing the overall profitability of marketing campaigns. Client X were left with the envious choice of either banking the extra profit, or lowering the overall ROAS target (now that the existing ROAS was more profitable than previously) allowing for a massive increase in revenue.
Conclusions
This case study is yet another illustration of how the best digital marketers can learn to incorporate business variables and data previously unavailable to Google, into Google’s bidding solutions for fully optimized performance.
The transition from a ROAS to a POAS strategy has proved pivotal for Client X. Hypus implemented a comprehensive approach, analyzing profit factors, categorizing products, and choosing a sophisticated conversion action model that would allow the campaigns to be optimized for best possible POAS. The results have been transformative; maintaining ROAS but significantly enhancing campaign profitability, and at no extra advertising costs.





